Skip to main content

Origins vs. Garnier: Dupe, Dud or Better??

Hello, beauties!!

Welcome back to my humble blog! Today, I'm actually coming with a review and comparison on two masks I own: the Origins Clear Improvement Active Charcoal Mask and the Garnier SkinActive Clean+ Pore Purifying 2-in-1 Clay Cleanser/Mask. Inspiried by one of my favorite Youtubers, The Glamour Index. I decided to dig into my own stash to see if the drugstore option of a product was a dupe, dud or better than its high end counterpart.  I've been testing these out for a little while, and I think I have a pretty solid idea on how these work for my combination skin and which I would prefer. So, if you're interested in hearing my thoughts, keep on reading!!

The Similarities

  • Charcoal is a prominent ingredient in both! Aside from use on the grill or absorbing poison, it helps to detoxify the pores , causing the skin to feel cleaned and smoother over time.
  • Each have some sort of clay also in the mask (White China Clay--Origins, Kaolin Clay--Garnier)
  • The packaging---both are in a squeeze tube with a closeable cap, which makes it less messy to get out and apply.
(As you can see, the Garnier one has been WELL loved lol. )
The Differences
  • The price: Garnier runs for about $6-9, Origins is $17-24 (depending on the size)
  • The size: Garnier offers 5 fluid ounces (equaling $1.20-1.80 per fluid ounce), while Origins comes in either 1.7 or 3.4 fluid ounces ($7.05-10 per fluid ounce)
  • The color: Origins seems to apply and dry a tad bit darker than the Garnier mask.
  • The uses: Since it is stated in the title, Garnier can be use as both a mask as well as a cleanser, whereas Origins is strictly a mask
  • The sensation: They both have a tingling sensation when applied and while drying, however Origins has a bit of a deeper clean in my opinion.
  • Availability: Garnier can be picked up at virtually any drugstore--Walmart, Kmart, RiteAid, Walgreens, CVS, Target, etc.; whereas Origins is found in more higher end stores--Sephora, Elder-Beerman, Macy's.

(Garnier on the left, Origins on the right. I was a little bot TOO excited lol)
What's the verdict??
In conclusion , I would have to say that they are dupes--even though Origins does clean my skin better and leave it smoother. I believe the Garnier does offer a pretty good alternative for those on a tight budget or can't get to the nearest Macy's or Sephora. But, overall I think they are both worth checking out if you have an issue with excess oil, clogged or enlarged pores or a stubborn breakout that just won't go away without a fight. If you have more dry skin, I would suggest using these masks more as a spot treatment, as they can tend to make the face feel tight and drier since it is absorbing all the oil and dirt out of your skin.

Well, hopefully this was helpful! Thanks so much for reading, and like always, Stay Beautiful!


Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Review: Nubian Heritage African Black Soap

Hello, all! Happy new year to everyone!! I came on to give my review on the second out of the three soaps I received from Nubian Heritage---the African Black Soap. Price: $4.99 on NH website and at the Vitamin Shoppe (5 oz size) Specs: This soap claims to be  acne-fighting,  detoxifying and healing.  Also, it was designed for people with   combination, oily, sensitive, and problem skin  , however it has been said that people with ALL skin types can use this as well :) but, back to the specs. Like I mentioned on my review on the Shea Butter soap , on the container is a brief history about how Nubian Heritage got its start and the ayurvedic properties about the key ingredients--which for this product line is shea butter, oats, aloe, palm ash, plaintain peel, tamarind extract and vitamin E. Palm Ash, Tamarind & Plantain Peel--soothing properties ; minimizes the appearance of superficial skin imperfections Oats--brightens and evens skin tone ...
Post a Comment
Read more

November Favorites

Hello, my loves! Welcome back & if you're new here, welcome! I can't believe that I'm here with my November beauty favorites!! Like the year is legit almost  done. 31 days left before 2018 makes its grand entry. I do have quite a bit this month, so if you're interested in learning all about my  favorites for November,  then just keep reading! SKIN/BODYCARE Eco Tools Konjac Cleansing Sponge : so great for helping spread my cleanser more evenly on my face versus using my hands or a rag! I've also noticed that it has helped my skin be a lot smoother, too! Shea Moisture Superfruit Complex Body Lotion : such a thick, hydrating lotion !! Only thing though is I would change the packaging--maybe opt for a jar instead of a bottle because it's thicker that a traditional lotion, but thinner than a body butter. Nip & Fab Kale Fix Protecting Shot : my skin has been more balanced lately since incorporating this oil!! Since it's colder, my skin tends t...
Post a Comment
Read more

August Favorites 2018.

Hola, beautiful ones!! Welcome back & if you're new here,welcome! Once again, we've reached the end on yet another month, which means monthly favorites! Guys, we're officially 2/3 through 2018!! Crazy that just in 4 short months, it will be 2019!! Slow down, time!! Nonetheless, I have some really good stuff that I've been loving, so if you guys wanna know about my favorites for August, then just keep on  reading! Makeup Colourpop Element of Surprise palette : this is probably one of the most unique palettes I own! When I first saw it, I had no interest in picking it up, but when I saw it in Ulta & swatched the shade Rayon, (metallic dark coral with blue-green duochrome) I fell in love!! I never thought I'd love this palette, but I'm pleasantly surprised! Colourpop x KathleenLights Dream St. Palette :  another great option for a few pops of color + neutral shades! Unlike the Element of Surprise, this one is more a warm toned color scheme .  Also, I...
Post a Comment
Read more